Nacho Average Grilled Cheese Recipe

When’s a grilled cheese more than a grilled cheese? When it’s a gooey, spicy, chunky griddle-toasted cheese sandwich. This version has fajita-style peppers and onions, spicy pico and cheese, and a smoky smear of mayo that makes the whole outside of the sandwich extra crispy. 

Trust us. You’re going to want to make extras. With a recipe this simple, we think we found your new favorite grilled cheese.


8 thick-cut slices of challah or sourdough (or your favorite bread)

8 oz grated pepper jack cheese

1/3 C pico de gallo (store-bought or homemade)

1 avocado

1 red bell pepper

1 yellow bell pepper

1 large onion

1 jalapeno, seeds and ribs removed then finely diced (optional)

1 Tbsp extra-virgin olive oil, plus a little for the griddle surface

Salt and pepper, to taste


1/4 cup mayonnaise

1 tsp smoked paprika


Step 1: Prep Your Ingredients

If the bread is a full loaf, slice it into thick pieces. Set aside. 

In a small bowl, mix the mayonnaise and paprika. Set aside. 

Chop the red and yellow bell peppers into 1-inch squares, and slice the onion into thick rings.

Toss with the tablespoon of olive oil. Salt and pepper to taste.

Step 2: Prep Your Griddle

Unlock your lid or fold-over side tables, and turn on your griddle. 

Turn the burners to high.

The powerful griddle will heat up quickly, so you’ll be ready to go in about a minute.

Season the surface with a thin layers of extra-virgin olive oil.

Step 3: Cook the Peppers and Onions

Lay your peppers and onions (and the jalapeno, if you’re using it) in a single layer on the griddle.

Cook them over medium-high heat, until they’re tender and charred to perfection.

Step 4: Assemble the Sandwiches

Smear the paprika mayo on the outside of each slice of bread.

With the spread side facing down, layer sandwiches with pico de gallo, shredded cheese,
charred peppers and onions, and the thin-sliced avocado.

Top with the other piece of bread — mayo side out (trust us).

Cook until the bread is toasted and the cheese is melted, about 2 minutes per side. 

Pro Tips

  • During the last minute of cooking on each side, cover the sandwiches with the griddle lid
    to ensure maximum cheese meltiness.
  • Use a sandwich press to compress the sandwiches, and distribute the melty
    cheese throughout.
  • You’ll have extra charred peppers and onions. Not a bad start to a delicious side dish or
    salad topping!

Step 5: Enjoy!

When your sandwiches reach your desired level of toastiness, remove from the griddle.

Want to get your hands on the high-powered griddle featured in this recipe? Buy it today!